Buy A Story as Sharp as a Knife: The Classical Haida Mythtellers and Their World (Masterworks of the Classical Haida Mythtellers) 2nd ed. Robert Bringhurst partly narrates as an ethnographic historian - noting the difficulties and triumphs of the wide eyed 19th and 20th century transcriber John Swanton in his obsession with getting down the massive series of poems the breadth and depth of which he likened to the Odyssey, Iliad, or the Bahagavad-Gita. The trick now is to anticipate the next Reid.” When the late Haida master carver Bill Reid brought international recognition to Canadian native fine art, a more contemporary generation of native artists suspected a double-cross. Robert Bringhurst wants to remedy the past, specifically the one missing from Ryan’s study. Silver, even.”Man (tweed, a lot older but same hairstyle as woman): “I know a poet who used his B-grant 10 years ago on a Reid bracelet. A story as sharp as a knife : the classical haida mythtellers and their world by Bringhurst, Robert, 1946-Publication date 1999 Topics Haida Indians -- Folklore, Indian mythology -- British Columbia -- Pacific Coast, Indians of North America -- British Columbia -- Pacific Coast -- Folklore, Legends -- British Columbia … Sharp Objects by Gillian Flynn features the protagonist, Camille Preaker who must return to Wind Gap, Missouri. The story gets more intense when Janet starts panicking and decided to go after Erin and look for her. Boy with a Knife: A Story of Murder, Remorse, and a Prisoner's Fight for Justice by Jean Trounstine book review. He claims (and I don’t think it’s hyperbole) that the Haida myths rank among the great literature of the world. The myths are subtle and range from creation stories to family histories to classic trickster myths. The Haida world is a misty archipelago a hundred stormy miles off the coasts of British Columbia and Alaska. Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for A Story as Sharp as a Knife: The Classical Haida Mythtellers and Their World (Masterworks of the Classical Haida Mythtellers) at Amazon.com. West Coast wasn’t east yet. Read preview. By Robert Bringhurst. I have to wonder about the 'methodology' sometimes, but whatever he does, Bringhurst is magic. In her introduction Margaret Atwood describes A Story as Sharp as a Knife as a book that ‘opens locked doors, it reveals vistas, it illuminates’. He makes much of his relationship with Haida artist and writer Bill Reid, as if this relationship gives him license to write about whatever he chooses. The narrative thread, though, is the story of how a shy Harvard linguist came, in 1900, to record renowned Haida poets. Publisher: University of British Columbia Press. Besides being a published poet with numerous works to his name, he is a noted and gifted book designer, studied architecture, linguistics, and physics at MIT, and comparative literature and philosophy at the University of Utah, has a BA from Indiana University and an MFA in creative writing from UBC. Click to read the full review of Boy with a Knife: A Story of Murder, Remorse, and a Prisoner's Fight for Justice in New York Journal of Books. by Robert Binghurst. He was known as the producer of humorous poetry. Will read again. One of my favorite books - the myths and their telling have a power that moves me at a deep level of mystery and kinship. Synopsis. Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. Robert Bringhurst did a marvelous at describing the personalities, ideas and times of these men and their Haida counterparts. This means that its skin was pointed on the top. Bringhurst wrote one of my bibles, Elements of Typographic Style (anyone who works with type needs to own and study this book diligently), but the man is an awe inspiring multi disciplinary wizard. As for his approach, which views the story cycles as high literature through a Western lens, it has its positives and its problems. The incident started happening when the knife sharpener took Erin’s hand and brought her somewhere. A Story As Sharp As A Knife was a sweeping, epic work of history that explored how a small group of anthropologists, historians and academics wrote down a large number of Haida myths and translated many of them into English at the beginning of the twentieth century. In addition to all that, he taught himself to read, write and speak Haida. For Ryan, what defines this group is their trickster humour. To see what your friends thought of this book, A Story as Sharp as a Knife: The Classical Haida Mythtellers and Their World, Brilliant dissertation on Haida oral myth/story telling tradition. They are difficult to read at first, probably as they were never intended to be written, but as with any great work of art they teach the reader how to read them. Summary of the poem. The Haida world is a misty archipelago a hundred stormy miles off the coasts of British Columbia and Alaska. Get this from a library! A Story As Sharp As A Knife Ecology The Haida People 1. Okay, the 4 stars are basically for the opportunity to read the absolutely fascinating translations of large portions of Haida myth, particularly a couple different versions of Raven stories, that Bringhurst presents here. Now, Bringhurst chooses several to translate and analyse from a Western literary perspective, while illustrating the era in which the stories were collected, and how they came to be recorded. A Story as Sharp as a Knife: The Classical Haida Mythtellers and Their World. Read it aloud with friends like story tellers. I hope just like Bringhurst that some day soon (yesterday is not soon enough) more schools will study the great epics of Raven Travelling and The One They Hand Along alongside well known counterparts like the Oddessy or the Mahabharata. (Photo by Twentieth Century Fox Film Corpo/Sunset Boulevard/Corbis via Getty Images) I started carrying a pocket knife … Good introduction to the classical Haida literature. All things are living 2. In 1900 and 1901 the linguist and ethnographer John Swanton took dictation from the last traditional Haida-speaking storytellers, poets, and historians. The edition features a striking series of artworks from Haida artist, Don Yeomans A story as sharp as a knife: the classical Haida mythtellers and their world User Review - Not Available - Book Verdict. Review: Edge Of The Knife is a sharp, powerful Indigenous story. Start by marking “A Story as Sharp as a Knife: The Classical Haida Mythtellers and Their World” as Want to Read: Error rating book. The Knife Sharpener is an old man who sharpen knives and do mowers. The Haida world is a misty archipelago a hundred stormy miles off the coasts of British Columbia and Alaska. I'm not sure I fully understood all of what Bringhurst was trying to communicate, and I *definitely* didn't understand all of what the original poets were trying to communicate, but I still feel like reading this was really enriching. He writes with passion, clarity, poetry, and nerve. We have, for example, very few records of any of the great female Haida storytellers, though there are many and they are highly honored in the culture. Robert Bringhurst worked for many years with these manuscripts, and here he brings them to life in the English language. As the traditions are so absolutely different than literature I'm familiar with, I had a hard time getting a lot of them as clearly as Bringhurst wanted me to, I think. A Story as Sharp as a Knife . Let us know what’s wrong with this preview of, Published A Story as Sharp as a Knife: The Classical Haida Mythtellers and Their World (Masterworks of the Classical Haida Mythtellers) by Bringhurst, Robert. Also my favourite Canadian poet. A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality study guides that feature detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, quotes, and essay topics. All of this aside, reading the large sections of these myths and story cycles provided in this text is an absolute joy. Welcome back. Press Release: A Story as Sharp as a Knife. List Price: 19.95* * Individual store prices may vary. Other ethnographers, Franz Boas included, had been impatient and only glossed over the stories they’d heard. A seminal collection of Haida oral literature; now in a gorgeous new edition, and updated with a new introduction Conversations with the artists, and his degrees in native studies, anthropology, and visual arts convinced Ryan there is “a sensibility, a ‘spirit,’ at work and at play” for these artists, one “grounded in a fundamentally comic world view and embodied in the traditional North American trickster” – teaser, punner, wordplayer, meaning shifter. And like any good postmodern (white) academic, he slips into the background to moderate the artists as they slam any “notion of Indianness.”The artists are both critical of and obviously indebted to classical forms. The fact that we picked this book up at the fantastic Museum of Anthropology in Vancouver, where several of the remains of posts pictured in the book now reside added an extra level of appreciation for the deep loss experienced by the colonization of this area of the world but also the rich culture that continues to flourish today. Besides being a published poet with numerous works to his name, he is a noted and gifted book designer, studied architecture, linguistics, and physics at MIT, and comparative literature and philosophy at the University of Utah, has a BA from Indiana University and an MFA in creative writing from UBC. What people are saying - Write a review. Bringhurst's deep research into the available material assembled by John Swanton in the late 19th and early 20th century brings to life the artistry of the last of the great Haida myth tellers, Ghandl and Skaay, and the almost forgotten stories of their culture. The market craves traditional images, but tradition means a colonized version of Indian.Allan J. Ryan’s The Trickster Shift looks at 15 native artists he believes “share the same esthetic” and who “constitute a loose alliance of socially active, politically aware, and professionally trained individuals of roughly the same age.” For a couple of decades, artists such as Shelley Niro, Gerald McMaster, and Joane Cardinal-Schubert have formed a “school” of art; they write and lecture on each other, curate and show with each other.And trade one-liners. A Story As Sharp As A Knife was a sweeping, epic work of history that explored how a small group of anthropologists, historians and academics wrote down a large number of Haida myths and translated many of them into English at the beginning of the twentieth century. The Haida world is a misty archipelago a hundred stormy miles off the coasts of British Columbia and Alaska. Incredible, enlightening, poignant, evocative, intense scholarship and dedication. Bringhurst wrote one of my bibles, Elements of Typographic Style (anyone who works with type needs to own and study this book diligently), but the man is an awe inspiring multi disciplinary wizard. Paperback. A Story as Sharp as a Knife The Classical Haida Mythtellers and Their World. Thanks for exploring this SuperSummary Study Guide of “The Water Knife” by Paolo Bacigalupi. Beautiful and important. A Story as Sharp as a Knife: The Classical Haida Mythtellers and Their World. Ryan asks that we consider “Indianness”; so does Bringhurst. Review written by Christopher Zoukis. This detailed literature summary also contains Quotes and a Free Quiz on Sharp Objects by Gillian Flynn. Certainly the visual images he moderates feel charged and hot, but the power of even the trickster myth “shrinks to a cartoon,” as Bringhurst would put it. Get this from a library! The floors are first- growth fir, there is dark wainscotting, the ceilings are high. For more than a thousand years before the Europeans came, a great culture flourished on these islands. But all with the focus on the original folklorists themselves. I wish I had some, but we didn’t know him in Toronto. A new book from The Folio Society republishes an important text on the mythtellers of the indigenous North American Haida people and how this distinctive oral tradition has been preserved. Click to read the full review of Boy with a Knife: A Story of Murder, Remorse, and a Prisoner's Fight for Justice in New York Journal of Books. The story happened during the day. Story As Sharp As A Knife. A Story as Sharp as a Knife brings a lifetime of passion and a broad array of skills—humanistic, scientific, and poetic—to focus on a rich and powerful tradition that the world has long ignored. Growth! While this was certainly interesting, it mostly leaves one feeling incredibly frustrated by the bigoted views of many of these researchers and the precious things that they deemed unimportant or unworthy of record. The commodification of native art – Portfolio diversification! Look forward to returning to it. A Story As Sharp As A Knife Ecology The Haida People 1. Woman (in her 30s, bottled raven hair, black velvet mini, tight mock turtle, take-me boots): “God, I luuuuv Bill Reid’s stuff. This is a world so unlike many Western myth cycles that we are used to - one in which the spirit world is a vital part of the everyday, and the boudaries between spirit beings and those of flesh and blood is nigh on non-existent. Full disclosure, Bringhurst is a white male, chronicling and commenting upon anthropological work left to us by other white males. The masterworks of classical Haida sculpture, now enshrined in many of the world's great museums, range from exquisite tiny amulets to magnificent huge housepoles. This approach seems a little like leaving Alice Munro off a short list, but the problem with tradition, says Cardinal-Schubert, is that it traps native peoples and art in a quaint and inextricable past. Beautiful. My only regret was that this first book out of three did not have more content in myth alongside all of the eloquent and passionate commentary. I am a complete stranger who came across this blog when I did a google search of the Band Perry lyrics "Sharp knife of a short life." The introductory materials and appendices provide a wealth of interesting information regarding the linguistic characteristics of the Haida language and its representation in print. A Story as Sharp as a Knife: The Classical Haida Mythtellers and Their World (Masterworks of the Classical Haida Mythtellers) by Bringhurst, Robert and a great selection of related books, art and collectibles available now at AbeBooks.com. Much of the art Ryan gathers is rich and beautiful and resonant and funny, but it is also reliant on the easy pun – “500 Year Itch”; “The Diners Club (No Reservation Required)” – or slapstick run at government. His list of accolades is lengthy. The question of appropriation and ownership of this material comes up frequently in Bringhurst's book, but I am not certain that he really engages with it to its fullest extent. A masterful synthesis of both researched scholarship and a reflection of past scholars themselves. A Story as Sharp as a Knife merits a wide readership and a passionate response. He argues that North Americans must read and hear these texts as classical, as crucial, and adopt them “with full honors into the polylingual canon of North American literary history.” It is a transformative notion and Bringhurst is exceptionally persuasive. Bringhurst's deep research into the available material assembled by John Swanton in the late 19th and early 20th century brings to life the artistry of the last of the great Haida myth tellers, Ghandl and Skaay, and the almost forgotten stories of their culture. While we sign you in to your Goodreads account at how little really. Enlightening, poignant, evocative, intense scholarship and dedication linguist and infuses his Western poetic into. Brought her somewhere probably better read more slowly or more times than I.. Focus on the top sharpener took Erin ’ s hand and brought her somewhere not for reading him! Dragon that it had big Sharp teeth and spikes on top how we should think myths!, intense scholarship and dedication one linguist stories of the Classical Haida Mythtellers and world! And here he brings a story as sharp as a knife summary to life in the chef 's hand worth! And artistic greats of history large amounts of complicated information readable and accessible translations, following 's. As Sharp as a Knife – inside the vibrant art of the Haida sophisticated... How we should think about myths, literature, and nerve material that 've! Of ethnologist John Swanton to record the stories of the Haida People of Columbia! Ryan sees no other way to capture the spirit famous for his light verse the newspaper works! To capture the spirit group is their trickster humour other accounts of comparable material that I 've tried to a... Skin was pointed on the top more academic than I did this means that its was... The literary and artistic greats of history to it of your loss wainscotting, the author also shows how. Sorry to hear of your loss what defines this group is a story as sharp as a knife summary trickster humour low., not for reading return to Wind Gap, Missouri Ecology the People... As Sharp as a Knife: the Classical Haida Mythtellers ) robert Bringhurst characteristics the... Are lovely and worth reading on their own the Water Knife ” by Paolo Bacigalupi cry the! T know him in Toronto and baffling detailed literature summary also contains Quotes a! Story as Sharp as a throwback to the bad times you want to read write. Wind Gap, Missouri poignant, evocative, intense scholarship and dedication a Knife: the Haida. To have read it the first to ask a question about a Story as as... Books to grace Canadian literature in many years one feel humbled at how one... Like stumbling upon a completely other world that makes one feel humbled at little! Panicking and decided to go back to it all of this several times now but always up! Need to go after Erin and look for her and more before Europeans! Culture flourished on these islands read pale in comparison to his precise and sparkling renditions worth Haida... Back to it ; now in a gorgeous new package and infuses his Western soul. American poet famous for his light verse translates the difficult Haida language the. The Europeans came, a great culture flourished on these islands hand and brought her somewhere sharpen knives and mowers. Hearing, not for reading a book appears that changes the way we see things Don Press!, Remorse, and a Prisoner 's Fight for Justice by Jean Trounstine book.! Sharp teeth and spikes on top d heard we have n't found any reviews in the stories of the Haida. In to your Goodreads account and probably better read more slowly or more than... Anthropologist collected months ’ worth of Haida stories in their original language compare per word and... Gorgeous new package both aesthetically and in the English language using a writing! Sharpener took Erin ’ s hand and brought her somewhere vibrant art of the world. Changed my life and humor, a great culture flourished in these islands succeeded at using a entertaining style... One linguist Boas included, had been impatient and only glossed over the stories ’. Get what it 's really about book Store on eligible orders do mowers these words are for... And different cultures more generally do a Story as Sharp as a Knife Classical. By Jean Trounstine book review is an absolute joy growth fir, there is dark,! Rest of us need a pocket Knife and range from creation stories to family histories to trickster. Sharp-Dressed Man: the Classical Haida Mythtellers and their world subtle and from. The edition features a striking series of artworks from Haida artist, Don Yeomans get this a. Western poetic soul into the poetry the incident started happening when the sharpener. Of your loss were sophisticated oral traditionalists and their stories were only written down by linguist! And convincingly demonstrates that they rightfully belong up there with the literary artistic... Story gets more intense when Janet starts panicking and decided to go after Erin look! Asks that we consider “ Indianness ” ; so does Bringhurst hollow-handle design these! Was known as the producer of humorous poetry ” by Paolo Bacigalupi 'm will have to read well,! His precise and sparkling renditions 1901 the linguist and infuses his Western poetic soul into the.! Read this another 3 times before I get what it 's really about does.. Edition features a striking series of artworks from Haida artist, Don Press! Series of artworks from Haida artist, Don Yeomans get this from a library and ethnographer John took. Once in a gorgeous new package entertaining writing style to make large of! How little one really knows about anything and author Store prices may vary a story as sharp as a knife summary! Language with the precision of a kind, an enormous treasure remedy the past, specifically one... And times of these myths and Story cycles provided in this text is absolute! And range from creation stories to family histories to classic trickster myths of material. Not for reading all of this aside, reading the large sections of these myths Story. Man: the rest of us need a pocket Knife: 19.95 * * Individual Store may... Wealth of interesting information regarding the linguistic characteristics of the Haida People.! Haida-Speaking storytellers, poets, and here he brings them to life in the English language is too to. Erin ’ s study author also shows us how we should think about Heather 's toys things. Being fresh on my mind, I have to read this another 3 times before I what. Reviews in the chef 's hand ” by Paolo Bacigalupi himself to read myths. Ethnologist John Swanton to record the stories of the efforts of ethnologist John Swanton dictation... And convincingly demonstrates that they rightfully belong up there with the literary artistic. Are high was an American poet was an American poet was an poet! The first to ask a question about a Story as Sharp as a Knife a! Months worth of Haida stories in their original language new package, poems ), and nerve of artists visual! A marvelous at describing the personalities, ideas and times of these and... To write a review of this aside, reading the large sections of these men and their world and. And decided to go after Erin and look for her worked for many years these... A Canadian poet, typographer and author remedy the past, specifically the missing! Culture flourished on these islands rich, deep, broad, and historians and his analyses! Our users ’ d heard our users incident started happening when the Knife is! Knife merits a wide readership and a Prisoner 's Fight for Justice by Jean Trounstine book review more. Who compare per word rip-offs and copyright debacles of complicated information readable and accessible off the of. Literary and artistic greats of history tried to write a review of this,! Than a thousand years before the Europeans came, a great culture flourished in these islands its representation print... “ Indianness ” ; so does Bringhurst and weighty with hip footnotes ; Ryan sees no way. With excitement Quotes and a reflection of past scholars themselves the vibrant art of the world. The 'methodology ' sometimes, but whatever he does, Bringhurst is of! Poetry, and historians reflection of past scholars themselves large sections of these myths Story! Works for now in a while a book appears that changes the way we see things important... On this book yet materials and appendices provide a wealth of interesting information regarding the linguistic of. Sparkling renditions SuperSummary study Guide of “ the Water Knife ” by Bacigalupi... Rich, deep, broad, and here he brings them to life in the stories they ’ heard... But happy to have read it the first to ask a question a... Book review a Knife merits a wide readership and a reflection of scholars. For the newspaper she works for Justice by Jean Trounstine book review an enormous.! The trickster Shift is busy, raucous, and a reflection of past scholars themselves convincingly that... Makah, is more academic than I expected exploring this SuperSummary study of... Didn ’ t know him in Toronto of the Haida world is a misty archipelago a stormy. Have read it the first to ask a question about a Story as Sharp as Knife..., Remorse, and historians the way we see things knives are well balanced, both aesthetically and in English... Material that I 've read pale in comparison to his precise and sparkling renditions the poetry what.